Steam Locomotive Ultra-Detailing in “O” Scale…PRR I1sa #4390

Even though I do a LOT of scratch building and brass bashing for my own railroad, in support of both my D&H and Erie fetishes (you gotta roll your own if your’re going to model steam for either of those roads), I also regularly take on commissions for other clients from both the U.S. and overseas.

This past spring (2010) I took on a box-stock US Hobbies PRR I1s project. The client, a physician from New England, wanted this loco as accurately detailed as was humanly possible. Using detailed images from the period for this loco, I took this generic Penn I1s and totally reworked it into ultra-detailed PRR I1sa #4390, as she appeared in 1953.

Ultra-detailed backhead and boiler of I1sa #4390 (click on image to enlarge, and then click again)

Backhead of #4390 after initial detailing…

Partial cab interior and boiler viewed from Fireman’s side (note the addition of the reach rods from the starter valve and the injector on both the steam supply and water dump sides of the valve). This is how the Fireman controlled these components without leaving the cab…

Broadside of Fireman’s side of the boiler, with details for this section of the boiler nearing completion…

Fireman’s side front end after having received the “WWII Beauty Treatment”…

Engineer’s side front end showing many additional details, including the Turbo-Generator exhaust steam pipe and standoff, that connects to the generator and exits along side the stack (an often overlooked detail)…

Boiler is regularly test-fit to the chassis during the detailing process, ensuring that proper running clearances are maintained between the new boiler details and all moving parts, i.e. drivers, rods, valve gear, etc…

Belpaire topside details showing the addition of the two reach-rods and rod-guides that control component steam supply. The rods penetrate the front cab bulkhead, and end over the top of the crew’s head. Their red handles can be seen in the very first image in this section.

http://mattforsyth.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/I1sa-detail-023.jpg

The arching whistle chord and guides from the whistle’s accuating lever and back to the Engineer can also be seen. This chord is made from 0.005 brass wire that has been anealed, formed and re-hardend, which allows it to take on and maintain this shape.

Here are all the components cooling, having come fresh from the paint oven.  All parts are baked at 175 degrees for three hours to cure and harden the paint. Paint for this model is ScaleCoat PRR Brunswick Green (DGLE). The paint is not applied directly to the primer coat, as it is too green from the bottle. Instead, after priming, the entire loco is first painted semi-flat black, and that coat is then baked. 48 hours later, the Brunswick green is applied.  Doing this dramatically darkens the green top coat to a near-black. Later, after lettering and clear, matte top-coat, this near black color throws off green hues in both natural and artificial light, just as a fresh, PRR paint job would have done on the prototype.

210-F-75b tender for #4390 nearing completion. It still lacks a tail light, marker jewels, and cab glass…

The completed I1sa #4390. Both the locomotive and tender were given a pristine, factory-level plus paint job and lettering. Per the customer’s request, no weathering was applied.

The completed I1sa #4390. Ready to ship to the customer…

Re-detailed with Post WWII front end…

Engineer’s side…

Fireman’s side…

Tender detail 3/4 view…

Water line hose connection detail to injector and Worthington BL4B feedwater heater…

Steam Loco Bash…UP 2-8-0 to D&H 0-8-0!!

In the 1920’s trains were getting longer and heavier, and larger steam switchers were needed to handle the load. To meet this need, and rather than buying new power, the frugal Delaware and Hudson chose to build a group of fourteen, heavy 0-8-0 steam switchers. They were home-built at their Colonie Shops from 1926 to 1930. The Company used running gear, frames and boilers from older, then in-service 1000 Series, E-5 Class  2-8-0’s  to create these large, powerful 0-8-0’s.

Firemans’ side view of home-built heavy 0-8-0 class B-7, #157 as she sits on the ash pits at the Carbondale engine facility in 1940. This loco is typical of the class with all locos being nearly identical, displaying only minor differences in tender length and capacity. #157 was one of the short-tendered variants. (Ed Hermans collection, image courtesy Robert A. Liljestrand)

Engineer’s side view of B-7 Class #157 resting between switching assignments in the Carbondale Yard, August 10, 1952. (Joseph A. Smith collection)

A second shot of the engineer’s side of the loco, as she sits on the ash pit at Colonie in 1944. (Robert A Dunn Photo)

]_________________________________[

I’ve scratchbuilt many “O” steam locos over the years, but I am always on the lookout for a suitable “donor loco” for a given project. Scratchbuilding, although VERY satisfying, is the longest path one can take in creating a desired prototype. As an example, the Erie S-Class Berk is very unique, and although US Hobbies did import the NKP and C&O Berks in quantity, NEITHER unit makes an acceptable donor as the base model for an Erie Berk conversion, so scratchbuilding is the ONLY answer.

In starting the D&H #157 project, I also thought about other 0-8-0’s that had been imported, but most are too small, and sport 51″ drivers. The D&H B-7’s were built from older consolidations and were equipped with 57″ drivers. After a bit of hunting, I determined that my best course of action was to walk the same path as the D&H did, and use a small consolidation as a donor. I looked at the plentiful PRR H-8, 9, 10 Class consols, but the drivers are too large at 62″. After a bit more investigating, I located a US Hobbies UP 2-8-0 with 57″ drivers…a GREAT place to start. I bought the loco, and this is how it look upon arrival.

Not a horrible paint job, but those “steam-roller” 0.172 “old school” driver tires have got to go!!! In fact, so does the paint and lettering.  Next stop is the lacquer thinner bucket and the bead blaster. And that tender…what to do with that? After a little thought, it occured to me that all I needed to do was shorten it, convert the bunker to coal, and I could use it on my Erie C-3a 0-8-0, which were equipped with coal Vandys by the builder, given that road’s early Harriman relationship.

All stripped and whistle clean, ready to be “de-constructed”…

Here’s the model with its drivers rough-turned to 0.145. I still need to press the centers in an extra 0.020, and remove material from the rear of the driver center. Then fine-turn the face to 0.130 and drop the flanges to 0.030. This final machining will give me a 0.005 to 0.007 raised face on the driver tire, which is a HUGE help in keeping a nice, crisp edge when painting the driver tires white, a D&H Company Standard on all in-service locos, from small switchers to Challengers. Tires were initially painted white when locos were new as well as after shoppings, but were also repainted on a regular basis as needed, keeping them bright white for the life of the loco. Note how the counterweights now hang out prototypically past the tire edge and driver face after the initial turning.

]_________________________________[ 

If one takes note, many early steam locos on The Anthracite Roads were equipped with a “kicked back” rear driver, be it a 2-6-0, 4-6-0, 2-8-0, or 4-8-0. In other words, rather than all driver axle centers being evenly spaced, the last axle in the driver set was moved rearward. This was done to extend the loco’s wheelbase because they lacked a trailing truck, providing additional support for the huge, anthracite-burning Wooten firebox.

Originally starting out as a 2-8-0, and then being converted to an 0-8-0, the Wooten-equipped D&H B-7 also has a kicked back rear axle. In addition, the loco frame’s original tailbeam will need to be modified to reflect the new prototype. Below is a basic 1/8″ scale drawing of the B-7.

(Draw by the late Lawrence C. Himrod, Binghamton, NY, March 15, 1963, Matt Forsyth collection)

  

This is a closeup image of the required tailbeam, and also shows the rearward-extended rear driver axle in better detail.

After complete dissassembly of the loco, the fame was put in a vice and the old tailbeam was cut off with a hacksaw. It was then milled on the Sherline miller using a 1/4″ 4-flute mill to create a step to accept the new tailbeam extension. While I had the frame fixtured, I also cut back the trailing edge of the rear bearing slot to achieve the kick-back offset and the correct B-7 rear driver spacing.  After the new beam is fabricated and installed, I will sweat a section of brass bar against the leading edge of the bearing slot to restore the original slot dimensions, and complete the kick-back. 

This is a full broadside of the frame post step and bearing slot cutting…

After cutting two short lengths of 2 ¼” x  3/4″ x 3/16″ thick brass bar, I soldered the two together to make a sandwich. I blued one side and after creating a paper template of the new beam from 100 lb. cardstock, I overlayed the template on the brass and scribed in the design. I fixtured the brass in the Sherline and milled out the openings and all the outside surfaces. I left some excess material on the inside of the top beam of the forward hole (red arrow). This is a mating surface and I temporarily need that extra material left in place for added rigidity. After the new beam is soldered on to the frame, I will go back in and mill that material away to a final, finished shape.

3/4 view, front and top…

 3/4 view rear and top…

The new extension is test-fit to the frame. Note the line scribed into the bluing past the trailing edged of the bearing slot (red arrow). The material to the right of the line still needs to be removed to complete the kick-back. I have left it in place temporarily to add strength to the tail beam solder joint area. Once the beam is completely soldered in place, I will mill the rear bearing slot back to this line, completing the axle re-spacing.  

Once satisfied with the final fit and dimensions, the two halves are heated, separated, and the excess solder cleaned off…

The two halves placed in their correct positions, ready for final fitment…

Final fitting, and everything looks great…

New beam has been fixtured to the frame and soldered into place. Soldering was accomplished with a standard Bernz-o-matic propane plumber’s torch with a pencil tip, rosin core solder, and Nokorrode paste flux.

Post-soldering view #2

Post-soldering view #3

Post-soldering view #4

Final post-soldering machining on the tailbeam to remove excess material is complete, as well as the addition of the new bearing slot filler. The drivers and springs have been dropped back in, kick-back is complete, and all looks good.

Here’s one last view, showing the new tail beam in detail. I still need to final-machine the drivers, as well as extend the last segment of the side rods to match the new kick-back. In all reality, I could have just “fudged it” and not worried about adding an accurate, prototypical D&H tail beam, but with no trailing truck, that beam will be a very obvious on the model, and anything other than a correct one would stick out like a sore thumb.

Obstacle Course for Challengers, 1952

(Original image coutesy “Trains” magazine, and Syracuse University Press) 

This diagram represents the track profile for the D&H Penn Division, running from south to north as viewed from left to right. The Division starts in Wilkes-Barre, PA (PRR Interchange), and ends at Nineveh, NY, where the Penn Division merges with the D&H’s own Susquehanna Division, and heads north to Albany, NY. 

I have made some modifications to the profile to highlight my modeling area. The red arrows indicate the start (Carbondale, PA) and the stop (Lanesboro, PA) of the portion of the Penn Division I am representing on my layout. All other Penn Divison trackage (representing both ends of the line) will be in the form of  off-scene, hidden staging. 

I have also highlighted some other areas of interest on the line to include the the Ararat Wye, “Little Starrucca” Viaduct (not to be confused with Erie’s own Starrucca Viaduct that was located in Lanesboro), Horseshoe (also known as Ash Fill) Curve, Jefferson Junction, Starrucca Viaduct, and Cascade Wye just north of Lanesboro, PA.

Most railroad bridges are named not for the town or region in which they are located, but the valley, creek, stream, river or other body of water they span. The Erie’s Starrucca Viaduct was not located on the Penn Division, but actually spans over it as well as Starrucca Creek (from which the structure takes its name), with the D&H Penn Division tracks running beneath it. The Erie’s own Delaware Division, which was part of their high-speed  Jersey City to Chicago main, passed over on the Viaduct.  In this shot, we see a D&H pusher pair in the form of a J-Class Challenger and an E-Class Super Consolidation assisting a Symbol and starting the southbound push from Lanesboro, and up the northern slope of Ararat Mtn. (William S. Young photo) 

This is an image of “Little Starrucca” viaduct, that is actually located in the town of Starrucca, PA….so much for railroad bridge naming conventions!!! This steel structure is approximately 650′ in length and rises above the valley over 100′. This bridge is a part of the original construction of the Erie Jefferson Division in 1870, and was built by the Erie, not the D&H. In this May 1950 view, we are looking southeast, and we see Symbol WM-5 (Wilkes-Barre-Mechanicville-5) heading north towards Lanesboro, where the train will swing back onto the D&H’s own rails for the trip to Mechanicville in upstate New York, near Albany. (William S. Young photo)